14 Best Restaurants in Door County, Wisconsin

If you’re visiting Door County, Wisconsin, chances are you’re spending your days exploring the great outdoors through all the scenic hiking trails and parks that this region has to offer. Beautiful places such as Cave Point County Park and Washington Island are wonderful spots to explore all day with your family. But did you know Door County is home to some delicious food and sweet treats as well?

While the Door Peninsula and surrounding areas of Wisconsin are known for their amazing selection of fresh cheese and seafood, you can find a wide array of cuisines ranging from amazing steakhouses to international specialties, wood-fired pizzerias, and local breweries.

You can find some of the best restaurants in Door County in Fish Creek, Sister Bay, Egg Harbor, Baileys Harbor, and Sturgeon Bay. These towns are also close to most of the top attractions located on the peninsula.

Due to the abundance of fresh ingredients produced locally in Door County, we can guarantee that you’ll absolutely love our recommendations for the best restaurants in Door County. So without further ado, let’s get into the best restaurants Door County has to offer!

Best Restaurants in Door County, Wisconsin

1. CHOP

Address: 2345 Mill Rd, Sister Bay, WI 54234

Topping our list of amazing Door County restaurants, we have CHOP, located in Sister Bay. The restaurant offers high-quality steaks and seafood. Each steak selection comes with your choice of four house-made compound butters, or you can stick to classic plain (and delicious) Wisconsin butter.

The menu changes seasonally, ensuring the highest level of food quality by using fresh ingredients. This modern and upscale eatery offers seating spread over two levels, the second of which is accessible via an elevator.

Bar seating is also available. CHOP is a bit on the pricier side but is definitely considered one of the top Door County restaurants due to its high-quality ingredients.

See Related: Fun & Best Things to Do in Appleton, Wisconsin

2. Nightingale Supper Club

Address: 1541 Egg Harbor Rd, Sturgeon Bay, WI 54235

If you don’t already know, supper clubs are a long-standing tradition in Wisconsin. Think classic Midwestern meets quasi-European-style slow dining with a warm and cozy ambiance and great food. One of the best supper clubs you can find in Door County is Nightingale Supper Club.

This casual eatery has been serving locals and tourists since it opened its…